Brooklyn Speculative Fiction Writers
  • About BSFW
    • Policies & Procedures
    • Album
  • Blog
    • Speculative Facts >
      • BSFW Pinterest
      • BSFW Speculative Facts
  • Author Bios
  • Join BSFW!
    • Contact Us
    • BSFW Members Page
  • Kaleidocast
    • Kaleidocast Submissions
  • Support BSFW

Speculative Fact #313: Thought Experiments and Thought Crimes

6/6/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
A company in Israel has developed a program which analyzes faces to determine traits about that person and spot potential criminals. They claim that they can pick out white collar criminals, great poker players, and even pedophiles. The technology uses a broad database of facial traits and features and cross references them with the characteristics of known criminals. In the same way that faces are largely predetermined by genetics, they argue that criminal aptitude is also inherited.
            They are attempting to sell their creation with the claim that they can determine who is likely to be a terrorist, which concerns both Israel and the USA. Understandably, these bold claims have been met with knee-jerk reactions among the public, with people comparing it to the antiquated pseudoscience of phrenology. The program, however, has already been contracted by the Department of Homeland Security, which means it might have a future here in America.
            Such technology can quickly become a slippery slope. Even ignoring the many experts that are critical or skeptical, it has serious ethical and legal implications. Supposing we use such methods to preemptively identify criminals; if it becomes normalized and acceptable, will we punish criminals before they commit crimes? In Philip K. Dick’s Minority Report, beings with precognitive mental abilities predicted crimes before they occurred, which eventually lead to departments dedicated to precrime. Is our behavior predetermined by nature or does environment mitigate inheritance? At what point does crime prevention become thought crime?


-Jonathan Hernandez
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    The Speculative Facts

         The purpose of this page is to inspire and inform writers.  Come to find that spark from the Picture Prompt of the Month, the Speculative Facts, our latest Pinterest Pins and the News Feed.  Come to BSFW meetings to take your story through its paces and on to publication.
    Speculative Fact contributions are researched and written by Jonathan Hernandez and Rob Cameron

    The Muse Tweets

    Tweets by @BSF_WRITERS

    Pinterest Picture Prompt

    Picture
    Just in time for Halloween!
    create social website
Great Stories, Grown Here
Proudly powered by Weebly